My neighbor- Bless her heart had to have them after this being the 3rd fence we have replaced between us in 20 years. We had to use silicon to fill the gaps. They cracked where we used a rot board on the bottom of the fence- they are plastic. They are not made to keep a fence from rot they are made to be able to put another post in when it does rot. They fill with water...now why would I want to tear my fence part in another 7 years and replace it. I did my research and actually found a product that works which we bought and used on the other side. Seals the post completely to prevent rot,but I will not mention it here out of respect. Waste of money, very ugly and they are not all the same exact dimension. Can not nail into them without completely cracking them. We are going to remove the Sleeves and try and salvage our fence. My advise is do not waste your money, worse you will not be happy and stare at them for however many years they last wishing you would have just sloped the concrete away from the post. Im 66 years old and am that unhappy to take the time to write this review, I dont even like to write deposit slips at the bank. I like The Home Depot too, but those other reviews I just read, are from the people that make them! The only thing they would be good for is the guy who said he made a removable section, but it will wobble
Dear Valued Home Depot Customer, "A great deal of confusion can be avoided by reading directions and/or calling for assistance. Our instructions, product, and website all have an toll free number and/or website to reference for assistance so we ask if a customer has questions to please call and we will assist to our best ability.
As evidenced by this reviewer’s comments, the instructions and use guidelines were not read or followed. Additionally, the review on this site are by actual customers and not fabrications. They are from people who bought the product, read the use and installation instructions, and are satisfied with the performance because when used as directed, the product works very well.
We have been in business for 18 years with over a half million Post Protectors in the ground and MANY satisfied customers. Post Protector is embraced by wood scientists, builders, building supply companies, engineers, architects, building code officials, to name a few. Even the pressure treated post’s chemical preservative manufactures like the Post Protector to be used in conjunction with their treatment:
"Barrier" protection will substantially increase the lifespan of any pole by protecting it from fungal & insect attack far more effectively than a preservative treatment alone can achieve while preventing preservatives from leaching into the environment."
As to the specific concerns as raised by this reviewer-
The instruction sheet provided in each uplift protection hardware pack clearly describes the proper and simple installation technique and we include a toll free number to call if there is a question or a unique application you’d like to discuss. Most posts are true to size but it is possible for posts to be over-sized & under-sized. Per the instructions, trimming or shimming may be required. The use of silicone is not recommended or suggested in instructions.
Post Protector is “Barrier” protection for in-ground posts. It allows for a post to be put in the ground without having direct ground contact. This is important as decay is CAUSED by soil dwelling fungi feeding on the wood fiber. NO soil-to-wood contact, NO soil fungi can access wood, NO DECAY. WATER ALONE DOES NOT CAUSE DECAY-Wood naturally has a large percentage of water in it naturally.
Post Protector was developed in conjunction with the Geo-Synthetics Institute, Drexel University, Philadelphia and Wood Scientist, Dr.Shane Kitchens. We understand how decay occurs and how to prevent it. First, if you watch the video with Dr. Kitchens on homedepot.com, he explains how decay occurs, how to prevent it, and why he, as a wood scientist for over 20 years, “highly recommends Post Protector to maximize in ground post life.” Secondly, in that video, Dr. Kitchens speaks to systems that try to “seal” the post and goes on to say that he “doesn’t particularly care for” that approach because “it is impossible to fully seal them” and that he likes the Post Protector approach.
Again, if you have any questions or concerns with the use of Post Protector, please contact us so we can review your project and provide assistance to make your installation a sucesses.