Hi Cb, thank you for your review. I'm so sorry to hear your paint was watery and did not provide the coverage you expected. Our Urethane Alkyd Enamel should have an even and creamy consistency. If that is not the case, I recommend stirring the paint for about 5 minutes to get it to the correct texture. As the paint is not a One-Coat Coverage Coating like our Marquee or Dynasty Paint, it will typically cover in 1-2 coats. However, additional coats may be needed for uniformity. In any case, we strive to provide a positive customer experience, and we appreciate your feedback. Please reach out to us directly if you need further assistance; our Customer Care team is happy to help! -Lina