Thank you for your review. We’re sorry that you're dissatisfied with this product. The Leather Shag Collection is hand knotted and each individual piece of leather is hand sewn into the foundation. The multiple leather pieces are likely produced separately from a dyed batch, resulting in different colored leather pieces. The color of the leather pieces used will vary from one another, resulting in the overall appearance of the rug being darker or lighter than the next. The color will vary in each production, so no two leather shags will appear the same in color.